Comment 44 for bug 802626

James,

I don't believe that's true. If the rootfs is in the same VG, there should be no possibility of udev being stopped in the initramfs prior to the dependent event making its way through the system, because without those events the rootfs can't be mounted at all. And certainly, root-on-LVM has been 100% reliable for me here. I think you should file a separate bug for the issue you're seeing.