Code review comment for lp:~bac/launchpad/bug-341935-captcha

08:11 < beuno> noodles775, good morning
08:11 < noodles775> hi beuno
08:11 < beuno> noodles775, looking at the captcha review
08:12 < beuno> it's a great point about telling people why we ask that
08:12 < beuno> I wonder if we could have a (?) icon, that is clickable, and mrevell's help popup comes up
08:12 < beuno> so we don't have so much text on the page
08:12 < noodles775> Yeah, that'd be a good way to keep it minimal :)
08:13 < beuno> the other thing that came to mind was, maybe the field shouldn't be that length
08:13 < beuno> to make it distincctivly different than password
08:13 < beuno> if you don't read labels, it's easy to be fooled
08:16 < noodles775> yeah, true - I hadn't thought of that - mistaking it for a password field simply because it's following the email field.
08:16 < noodles775> I had a quick look at a few other sites (gmail signup and ubuntu forums) and both define a label like "Random question" or "Word
                    verification", and are visually quite different...
08:17 < beuno> right, you may also be able to get away with a very short description
08:17 < beuno> I think the key here is that it look visually different enough
08:17 < beuno> this is where "don't read the merge proposal" comes in useful :)
08:18 < noodles775> So, laying it out like the gmail signup:
08:19 < noodles775> hmm... not sure what we'd use for a label, but having the actual simple math question in the right section (ie. aligned with the inputs)
                    and the input below it could do that.
08:20 < beuno> yeap, that would work
08:21 < noodles775> perhaps the label could simply be 'Random question'.
08:21 < beuno> yeah, or "spam test"
08:21 < beuno> something that gets the message across
08:21 < noodles775> I'll play with it and do a diff.
08:21 < beuno> it's a great point that the label is not a good place to put the question